Akreditasi

Jurnal Profesi implements a rigorous and transparent peer-review process to maintain the scientific quality, originality, integrity, and academic contribution of all published articles. The journal is committed to publishing high-quality scholarly works that contribute to the development of professional knowledge, professional education, professional practice, ethics, competencies, and innovation in relevant professional fields.
All submitted manuscripts undergo an initial editorial evaluation followed by assessment by qualified reviewers with expertise relevant to the manuscript's subject area.
The peer-review process is conducted objectively, independently, constructively, and in accordance with established principles of research integrity and publication ethics. Editorial decisions are based on the scientific merit, originality, methodological rigor, relevance, and contribution of the manuscript to the journal's aims and scope.
Decisions regarding manuscript acceptance, revision, or rejection are made by the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized handling editor, taking into consideration the reviewers' recommendations and the journal's editorial policies.
All manuscripts submitted through the Open Journal Systems (OJS) platform undergo an initial screening by the editorial team to assess the following criteria:
The editor may reject a manuscript during the initial screening stage (desk rejection) if it falls outside the journal's scope, fails to meet basic submission requirements, contains fundamental methodological deficiencies, or does not satisfy the minimum scientific and editorial standards required for further evaluation.
Manuscripts that successfully pass the initial editorial screening may undergo a similarity check using plagiarism detection or text-matching software available to the journal.
The purpose of similarity screening is to assist editors in identifying potential plagiarism, inappropriate text reuse, duplicate publication, and other concerns related to manuscript originality.
Similarity scores are not used as the sole or automatic basis for editorial decisions. The editor evaluates the nature, source, context, and extent of textual similarities before determining whether further investigation or editorial action is necessary.
Manuscripts containing substantial evidence of plagiarism, redundant publication, or serious violations of publication ethics may be rejected in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policies.
Manuscripts that meet the initial editorial requirements are assigned to qualified peer reviewers selected according to the following considerations:
Reviewers may be selected from institutions different from those of the authors to support the independence and impartiality of the evaluation process.
The editor is responsible for selecting appropriate reviewers and ensuring that the review process is conducted in accordance with the journal's editorial standards.
Jurnal Profesi adopts a Double-Blind Peer Review model.
Under this model, the identities of the authors are concealed from the reviewers, while the identities of the reviewers are concealed from the authors throughout the peer-review process.
This approach is intended to minimize potential bias, protect reviewer independence, and promote fairness and objectivity in manuscript evaluation.
Reviewers are expected to assess manuscripts based on their scientific quality, originality, methodological rigor, relevance to professional disciplines, and scholarly contribution.
Evaluations must not be influenced by an author's identity, institutional affiliation, academic position, nationality, gender, personal background, or other characteristics unrelated to the scientific merit of the research.
Authors and reviewers are expected to avoid actions that could compromise the confidentiality or impartiality of the review process.
Reviewers are requested to provide objective and comprehensive assessments of submitted manuscripts based on the following criteria:
For manuscripts addressing professional practice or service delivery, reviewers may also consider the relevance of the findings to service quality, professional accountability, patient or client safety, and improvements in professional performance, where applicable.
Reviewers are encouraged to provide detailed, constructive, and evidence-based comments that assist authors in improving the scientific quality, clarity, relevance, and overall presentation of their manuscripts.
After completing the manuscript evaluation, reviewers may submit one of the following recommendations to the handling editor:
Reviewers' recommendations serve as an important basis for editorial consideration but do not automatically determine the final publication decision.
The final decision remains the responsibility of the Editor-in-Chief or the designated handling editor.
When revisions are required, authors will receive reviewers' comments and editorial recommendations through the journal's OJS platform.
Authors are expected to:
If additional time is required to complete the revisions, authors may contact the handling editor to request an extension before the specified deadline.
The editor may return the revised manuscript to the original reviewers or appoint additional reviewers when further scientific evaluation is necessary.
Submission of a revised manuscript does not guarantee acceptance for publication.
The final editorial decision regarding a submitted manuscript is made by the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized handling editor.
Editorial decisions are based on a comprehensive evaluation of the following factors:
Possible editorial decisions include acceptance, a request for further revision, or rejection.
All decisions are made independently and are based on scientific merit and established editorial standards. The journal does not guarantee publication solely on the basis of an author's academic position, institutional affiliation, professional status, or other considerations unrelated to manuscript quality.
When reviewers provide substantially different or conflicting evaluations, the editor may take appropriate measures to ensure a fair and well-informed editorial decision.
Such measures may include:
The editor will evaluate the recommendations collectively rather than relying solely on the number of positive or negative recommendations.
The final decision remains the responsibility of the editorial team.
All manuscripts submitted for peer review are treated as confidential documents.
Reviewers must maintain strict confidentiality throughout the review process and after its completion.
Reviewers are not permitted to:
Confidentiality obligations remain in effect even after the review process has concluded, regardless of the final editorial decision.
Editors are also responsible for protecting confidential manuscript information and editorial communications in accordance with the journal's policies.
Reviewers must promptly disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that could compromise their independence or objectivity.
Conflicts of interest may arise from professional, academic, personal, institutional, financial, or other relationships involving the authors, their affiliated institutions, or the research under evaluation.
Reviewers who identify such conflicts must notify the handling editor before accepting or continuing the review assignment.
Where a conflict of interest may affect the fairness or integrity of the assessment, the reviewer may be required to withdraw from the review process and be replaced by another qualified reviewer.
Editors must also disclose and appropriately manage their own conflicts of interest. Manuscripts involving an editor as an author or otherwise presenting a conflict of interest must be handled independently by another qualified editor.
The Editorial Board is responsible for managing conflicts of interest in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policy.
Reviewers play an essential role in maintaining the scientific quality, integrity, and professional relevance of the journal.
All reviewers are expected to:
Authors are responsible for ensuring the accuracy, originality, integrity, and ethical compliance of their submitted manuscripts.
Authors must:
Authors are expected to cooperate with editors and reviewers to ensure a fair, transparent, and effective evaluation process.
Jurnal Profesi strives to conduct editorial screening and peer review efficiently while maintaining high standards of scientific rigor and evaluation quality.
The time required to complete the review process may vary depending on several factors, including:
The journal aims to communicate editorial decisions and revision requests within a reasonable timeframe. Specific review targets, if established, will be communicated through the journal's official website or author guidelines.
The duration of the peer-review process is not guaranteed and may vary among manuscripts.
Jurnal Profesi is committed to maintaining editorial independence, impartiality, transparency, and ethical integrity throughout the manuscript evaluation and publication process.
Editors and reviewers must not discriminate against authors based on personal identity, institutional affiliation, academic position, nationality, gender, professional status, or other characteristics unrelated to scientific quality.
Editorial decisions must be based on the manuscript's:
Editors and reviewers are expected to uphold the principles of academic freedom, fairness, confidentiality, and responsible scholarly communication.
The general peer-review workflow of Jurnal Profesi consists of the following stages:
Manuscript Submission → Initial Editorial Screening → Similarity Check → Reviewer Selection → Double-Blind Peer Review → Editorial Decision → Manuscript Revision (if required) → Re-review (if required) → Final Editorial Decision → Copyediting and Production → Publication
Workflow Description
Stage 1: Manuscript Submission
Authors submit their manuscripts through the journal's OJS platform in accordance with the journal's submission guidelines.
Stage 2: Initial Editorial Screening
The editorial team evaluates the manuscript's relevance, completeness, formatting, scientific quality, and compliance with publication ethics.
Stage 3: Similarity Check
The manuscript may be examined using similarity detection software to identify potential plagiarism, inappropriate text reuse, or duplicate publication.
Stage 4: Reviewer Selection
The editor appoints qualified reviewers with relevant expertise and no disqualifying conflicts of interest.
Stage 5: Double-Blind Peer Review
Reviewers independently assess the manuscript's scientific quality, originality, methodology, professional relevance, and contribution to the relevant discipline.
Stage 6: Editorial Decision
The editor evaluates the reviewers' recommendations and determines whether the manuscript should be accepted, revised, or rejected.
Stage 7: Manuscript Revision
When revisions are requested, authors revise the manuscript and provide detailed responses to reviewers' comments.
Stage 8: Re-review
Revised manuscripts may undergo further evaluation by the original reviewers or additional reviewers, where necessary.
Stage 9: Final Editorial Decision
The Editor-in-Chief or designated handling editor makes the final decision based on the manuscript's scientific merit, review outcomes, and adequacy of revisions.
Stage 10: Copyediting and Production
Accepted manuscripts proceed to copyediting, proofreading, formatting, and other necessary production procedures.
Stage 11: Publication
Following completion of the editorial and production processes, the article is published in accordance with
Akreditasi

Plagiarism Checker

Reference Manager

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.